Regulation? Where do we draw the line?

Brief Summary:
Reasonable regulation can protect communities from genuinely harmful development, but excessive regulation threatens property rights, creativity, and freedom. By imagining musicians such as Bach, Elvis, The Beatles, and Shostakovich subjected to the same approval process as land developers, this page asks where society should draw the line. The restrictions we impose on others can eventually expand to restrain everyone, including our own selves: The chains with which we bind our neighbor may someday bind us.



Should Elvis, The Beatles, Madonna, and Shostakovich be told what kind of music they can and can't make?

“Where an excess of power prevails, property of no sort is duly respected. No man is safe in his opinions, his person, his faculties or his possessions.” James Madison

President Ronald Reagan on Regulation of Property Rights

“Freedom For Me, But Not For You” Milton Friedman

Having a Little Fun With This Funny But Serious Question:

Funny Grok AI Cartoons - Funny ChatGPT Cartoons

Funny Sponge Bob Episode on To Much Regulation

As a land developer, I’m hypersensitive to my work being heavily regulated. Literally every aspect of what I do is completely subject to the regulation of local politicians and professional staff. And, everything they do is heavily driven not only by neighbors near my projects, but also by residents miles away on the other side of town, and very often officials and residents of other cities. I am regulated on everything from what I can build (big house versus little house versus town house versus apartment versus retail shops versus drive-thrus versus office versus warehouse versus car wash versus self-storage, everything) to every finite detail (color, architecture, window placement, landscaping, driveway and parking, everything). In spite of my freedom loving, regulation resistant personality, I have come not only accept but to respect the need for a reasonable amount of regulation in my business. Land use decisions last a long, long time and impact generations to come both for good and bad. Shoddy development, incompatible projects, poor street and traffic planning, all of these can leave a wake of negative quality of life that can be very difficult for future generations to fix. Conversely, good development with good thought toward compatibility and transitions, good planning for infrastructure, traffic, parking, noise, just overall good planning can make a community look, feel, and live great for generations to come. My personal philosophy around development, deeply influenced by my father, is that even with or without regulatory oversight, I would aspire to all of those good planning principles, just because it is the right way. But, I also understand that not all developers think that way. And, I also understand that no matter how lofty I believe my development philosophy is, others impacted by my development decisions may or may not trust me and may or may not share my vision for what constitutes good planning and appropriate development. Thus, I have learned to not only accept, but respect the need for community engagement and local government regulatory oversight.

Seems simple. But, it gets more complicated. If all of that community engagement and regulatory oversight by elected officials, professional staff, and neighbors was predominantly moderate, balanced, rational, fair, respectful of market realities, respectful of my basic rights and a property owner, I could go about my work as a developer, incorporate excellent ideas from all of those impacted stakeholders, and go on to build good quality projects. Often, that is actually how things go, and that is great. But, quite often, all of that regulation and engagement is much more subject to opinion, taste, mood, bias, misinformation, political agenda, irrational thinking, whim, anger, and vitriol. That has gotten so much worse in the mob frenzied age of social media. The role of “Land Developer” has become almost a cartoon caricature. You can’t hardly watch a Hallmark Movie without seeing some greedy, heartless developer portrayed as the villain, come to destroy the small town with some cruel and devious scheme. It is a cliche, it is entertaining, for some I guess, but it is actually a harmful stereotype. Sure, bad development can happen and there are horror stories in real life. Thus, the appropriate need for regulatory oversight. But, the vast majority of what developers do is to provide exactly what people and communities need and ask for. Every home (big, medium, little, apartment), every store, shop, restaurant, every office or workplace, all of it is the result of some developer taking massive financial risk to build that. It goes much farther than that. The public infrastructure, the roads, the sewer lines, the water system, the parks are all funded either directly by developers building them at their cost or the city building them using impact fees brought in by the developers or the sales tax generated by the residents brought in by the developer. It sure seems comically common to hate and demonize a developer. But, everyone who does that lives in a house or apartment built by one and gets there on a road paid for by one and goes shopping or out to dinner at a place provided by one. I've seen the pattern countless times. People move to a town, get their little piece of the American Dream (largely built by the risk of a developer) then scream "slam the door shut behind me, and stop that evil developer!" when a developer wants to build some more of that dream for someone else.

We’ve reached a place where quite often developers are expected to take all the risk but have very little of the decision making about what they build. And, they get to be vilified as heartless devils who care about nothing but the dollar, anxious to get in, make the buck, get out, and leave a mess for someone else to clean up. This isn’t always the case. But, as the decades march on, this becomes more and more the case. I’ve written extensively about this dynamic elsewhere (Zoning Law, Building Permits, Righteous Dominion, 2014 Shane Krauser Radio Interview, etc.). I summarize it here to set the stage for a much bigger question that goes far beyond my little corner of the world as a land developer. I just use my experience as a heavily regulated land developer as a backdrop.

The question? How much regulation in our lives is too much, and where do we draw the line?

To address that question, imagine other acts of human creation, expression, development, building, thinking, production, teaching or invention being regulated in the way my world of land development is regulated. Granted, the impacts of land development are more permanent and potentially negatively impactful than most other lines of work. So, there is some apples and oranges with me framing it this way. But, maybe it’s not so different. Go with me on this for a minute. Take whatever it is you do, create, think, author, compose, produce, build, and imagine being regulated at this level. Let me frame that around my other great passion, music. We live in a world today, in this country certainly, that anyone can make any music they want, however they want. The last decade of home recording studios and music technology becoming so much more powerful and sophisticated combined with social media providing a global vehicle to share that music has been awesome. I compare the fifth grade me in the late 1970’s trying to make music in isolated bedroom with very crude music making tools compared to what I see people of all ages doing now on YouTube, FaceBook, etc. I love it. You get everything from brilliant to mediocre to downright lame. But the fact that those with the creative hunger have access to so many incredible production tools and so much online reach to get their ideas out there is a wonderful thing. The economics of that are as all over the map as is the creative quality and output.

Now, take all that and ask the question, what if someone decided that music making and distribution needed to be regulated the way my land development business is regulated. From now on, nobody can create music without first getting permission and approval from a local city council with a professional staff in charge of creating rules and regulations as to what kind of music can and can’t be created. And, every time you want to create some new music, you have to meet not just with neighbors, but people who live miles away so they can tell you why they will be harmed by the music you want to create and why you should use your time, resources, and creative energy to create the kind of music they want to hear, not the music you want to create. Then, after the staff has gone through the entire proposal of what you wish to create, told you why you can’t do that, changed it extensively, and then after all that still recommends denial to the city council, now you have to go to a public hearing so the city council can deliberate and vote whether you should be able to create that music you wanted to create. Every note, tone, chord, harmony, rhythm, instrument choice, lyric, every aspect of everyone’s musical desires would have to run this gauntlet before it can actually be created. Yuck! That might stop a lot of bad music. But, good music creation would cease to all except those with deep pockets to hire the zoning attorney equivalent of a music regulation attorney, or have massive patience and determination to run that bureaucratic gauntlet.

Here is how this could play out. I'll describe some of my life as a land developer using terms and concepts from my life as a music creator going to the neighbors, staff, and city council to get approval for music I would like to make. I'll have a little fun with this, and it might start to sound absurd. But, from my experience, this isn't that far off from reality and isn't as absurd as it may sound:

  • Your music has too many notes.
  • Your music doesn't have enough notes.
  • You can't use that chord in that spot.
  • Viola isn't allowed in that part of town.
  • You have to put an oboe in that spot right there.
  • In our town we don't want rock music. It's not part of our vision.
  • In our town we only want rock music. That's our vision.
  • You have to write classical orchestral music, we believe in tradition.
  • You can't write classical orchestral music, that's too old.
  • We already have too much punk rock music, we need more country music.
  • You're supposed to use a Gibson guitar there, not a Fender.
  • Do NOT use the Phrygian scale in our town. You can ONLY use the Ionian and Aeolian. You can use Dorian sparingly but only if we pre-approve your method of implementation.
  • We're tired of country music, we need more techno.
  • In our town, every song must have a reference to a horse.
  • You have too many horses and chickens in your song.
  • That melody will increase crime in my neighborhood.
  • I want you to make something that sounds like Britney Spears, not Jeff Beck.
  • You can't write any more music until we figure out what music everyone else in our town is going to write so that all of it can be coordinated.
  • We decided 30 years ago what kind of music people would be writing in our town and your music doesn't fit with that plan. Stick to the plan!
  • You sound too much like Gustav Mahler. We need you to sound more like Mozart.
  • Christopher Rouse? Miles Davis? What is that horrible noise? Give me some Hank Williams!
  • Seriously, Hank Williams? You need to make some Van Halen.
  • Your song is too long.
  • Your song is too short.
  • The song you want to write doesn't benefit me in any way, so you can't write it. Your song either needs to get me a job or a really nice coffee shop by my house or you can't write it.
  • We don't really know anything about how music gets made, and certainly wouldn't know how to make it ourselves. But, we still know better than you do what kind of music you need to be making.

Now, your response to this bizarre hypothetical world might be to call the comparison absurd. But is it? You might say that music that someone writes has no real impact on neighbors and community therefore who cares what kind of music someone creates and why would we ever want to regulate that? Well, first of all, music does have vast impact on society and culture. It has major influence on the philosophy, politics, and morality of all generations. Therefore, it does have deep and far reaching impact on neighbors and community. I happen to love and be moved by all kinds of music from Waylon to Mahler to Cash to Van Halen to Imagine Dragons to Bach to Miles Davis to Stravinsky to Bluegrass to the most intense contemporary classical music. Think of the social, cultural, and political implications of music created by the Beatles, Elvis, Marvin Gaye, Queen, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Nirvana, R.E.M., Bob Dylan, Simon and Garfunkel, Bob Marley, Madonna, Michael Jackson, Joni Mitchell, Neil Young, Billie Eilish, Taylor Swift, Lady Gaga, Beyonce, Adele, Frank Sinatra, Mamas and the Papas, Johnny Cash, Loretta Lynn, Eminem, Ozzy, Kanye, Jay-Z, Jason Aldean, Toby Keith, George Strait, Waylon and Willie, Hank Williams, this list could go on endlessly. For good or bad, all of these people have had influence on our world, our thinking, our kids, our community, how we treat each other, and our quality of life far more than anything I’ll ever build as a land developer. And, for many, their influence will last decades if not centuries longer than some of what I will build. Most people may not realize it, but the influence of Bach and Beethoven are deeply embedded in our lives centuries after they are gone. Bach died in 1750, sixteen years before the 1776 birth of our nation, 39 years before the US Constitution. Bach remains the absolute definitive framework for how nearly all music is created. Very little development has lasted anywhere near the 275+ years since his death. Much development doesn't even last the 39 year span between his death and the US Constitution. Yes, music can be vastly more enduring. Can you imagine some city council in the 1730's passing a law that says Bach could only write 3 of those Preludes and Fugues that ended up defining music instead of the 48 he actually wrote or that he couldn't write them at all because whoever was in charge at the time had other ideas on what he should write? We celebrate the freedom with which musicians and artists create. Why do we put such a choke-hold on development?

Buildings wear out over time, get knocked over, and something else new goes up, eventually. The ideas and influence of music can ring through generations and some of that will never die. And, there is vast difference of opinion as to whether the influence of a particular artist is good or bad. Some people see Madonna and Lady Gaga as undermining the moral fabric of our society, wrecking generations to come by poisoning our youth. Some say they are heroes, a vanguard of progressive ideas and freedom of thought. The same fierce debates were had about Elvis and the Beatles, the jazz musicians of the generations before. In fact, you can go back centuries in time as each new evolution of music caused a new round of upheaval, push back, desire to silence, and debate. Beethoven rocked the world that was used to Haydn and Mozart, Mahler rocked the world was used to Beethoven, Prokofiev, Shostakovich, each new wave of ideas rocked the world it was born into. The 1913 premiere of Stravinsky's masterwork The Rite of Spring triggered a now legendary reaction by some of the audience being disgusted and enraged by his music that "was cacophonously loud, assaulting the ears with thunderous percussion and shrieking brass." (Source). Seems like a pretty typical reaction to Elvis, The Beatles, and any number of past or present musicians. The real question is, who gets to decide what is good and bad, desirable or harmful? Would we really want a local government making those decisions for us?

But, you might say, we would never regulate music the way we regulate land developers. Or would we? Or have we? I have my own views about how much I want my grandkids influenced by Madonna versus the Beatles versus Miles Davis versus Bruno Mars versus Stravinsky versus Beethoven. I have sat with each brand new grandchild and played Mahler Symphony #2 because that music is so important to what I want to teach them. I care deeply about my grandkids and care deeply about what guides their beliefs, future, and every aspect of their quality of life including spiritually, intellectually, culturally, and economically. One could argue (with all kinds of hypocritical contradiction I'm sure) that Madonna could do more long lasting harm to future generations than an apartment complex or car wash down the street. The car wash is sure to stir up all kinds commotion. Some will hate it and run down to city hall torches and pitch forks in hand. Some will love how easy it will now be to have a clean car option nearby. A new song by Madonna goes mostly unnoticed by most people, but will be around for decades making whatever impact its going to make for good or ill. But, do I want Madonna to have to go to a neighborhood meeting and a city council hearing and go through layers and layers of professional staff review and music rules and regulations before she can make a new song? Can you imagine the music that would never have gotten made if we lived in that world? Yet, The Smothers Brothers got their show canceled because they were too controversial. Elvis was constantly told what he couldn’t do. I saw the movie, he was told he couldn't even lift a finger. Had to love it when he did it anyway! When I went to music theory school (yeah, I really did that!), I learned the lore that in Medieval times, the tritone interval (augmented 4th) was referred to as Diabolus in Musica, or the Devil in Music, and was banned from use in the church for being too dissonant. Ironically, that interval is one of the most essential elements of music from Bach to The Beatles to George Strait. It turns out there is actually way more to that story here and in this video. All of that, including the mythology, actually underscores that there has always been an undercurrent some people wanting to make rules for music (regulation) and others wanting to break those rules (innovation). In this case it was people retroactively saying there was a rule and expecting people to follow it even though the reality wasn't that clear. Suffice it to say that whether for religious reasons, cultural reasons, political reasons, or any other number of reasons, music creators have always had someone telling them what they can and can not create.

There are even more extreme examples in living memory. Gustav Mahler, one of the greatest composers of all time, certainly one of my very favorite, was banned by Hitler and the Nazi's. They also banned or regulated many other great and important composers including Mendelssohn, Schoenberg, and Hindemith. "The Nazis also regulated jazz, including the banning of solos and drum breaks, scat, "Negroid excesses in tempo" and "Jewishly gloomy lyrics"." (Source: Same link above.) Seriously? Jazz? The great American expression of freedom! Miles Davis was one of the great pioneers and masters in jazz and American music. Read here to see how he was brutally mistreated, not at all unlike so many other great jazz musicians right here in our own land of the free. Another one of my all-time favorite composers is the Russian Dimitri Shostakovich. To me his music is brilliant and inspiring. But, he spent much of his life under the heavy and potentially deadly thumb of Lenin and especially Stalin telling him what he could and could not compose. That is far worse than a city council meeting. Ironically, that's the same guys who nearly destroyed humanity with their brutally bad idea called communism. But, that illustrates the very point I’m going after. Sure, it might seem absurd to compare land development regulation to this seemingly made-up hypothetical world of music being regulated at the same level. But, think through what I've said. If land use regulation is about protecting the future, then I believe I have made a case that music has as much if not more impact on the future than land use? But, I would hope that most of us think regulating music at the level we regulate land use would be absurd. Should that give us any pause as to the level we regulate land use? The more we as a society demand more and more regulation of people like land developers, the more we set the stage for other things to be more and more regulated, and the less absurd my comparison. Across the board, we live in a much more regulated world than a few decades ago and certainly than a century ago. That isn’t all bad. But, because we’ve become so numb to the successive new layers upon layers of regulation, we are numb to the harm we have created for ourselves. Thus, my question: How much regulation in our lives is too much, and where do we draw the line?

Now, take all this an apply it to what you do, to what you create, to what you build, to what you think. Apply it to the things you like to do in your personal life. Ask yourself that question, how much do you want to be told what you can and can’t do? Where do you want that line drawn? Do you make hamburgers, furniture, or sell bikes? Do you teach in a school? Do you design software or smart phone apps? Do you sell stuff in a store? Do you make food at a restaurant? Are you an author who writes fiction or non-fiction? Are you a plumber or a car repair shop? For every profession, and every personal lifestyle, including yours, there are good arguments as to why certain aspects of what you do should be regulated. There is a reason there is regulation to prevent food poisoning from hamburger sellers selling bad meat. But, think also of all the ways that in your personal life and in your profession regulation can go too far. Whether in the context of my very real-life example as a land developer, whether in my only partially hypothetical example of music regulation, or in your own life experiences, personal life, and profession, think long and hard, where do we draw the line? Because, that line continues to move farther and farther down the road of more and more rules and regulation and less freedom to create, build, do, be, invent, buy, sell, think, produce as we wish. If you are going to demand that developers like me get regulated at increasingly higher levels, be prepared for everything else to eventually get regulated the same, including the stuff that you do. The chains with which we bind our neighbor will someday bind us.

These ideas are also addressed in The Story of Cabbage Pie, Chains That Bind, Righteous Dominion, Stop This Madness (Gilbert's 2024 Junk Ordinance), and my 2014 interview with Shane Krauser.

President Ronald Reagan addressed this head on (more on that here):

President Reagan on Property Rights and Socialism:

"Now it doesn't require expropriation or confiscation of private property or business to impose socialism on a people. What does it mean whether you hold the deed or the title to your business or property if the government holds the power of life and death over that business or property? Such machinery already exists. The government can find some charge to bring against any concern it chooses to prosecute. Every businessman has his own tale of harassment. Somewhere a perversion has taken place. Our natural, inalienable rights are now considered to be a dispensation of government, and freedom has never been so fragile, so close to slipping from our grasp as it is at this moment." President Ronald Reagan (Full Text and Video Here - Direct Link to Quote Here)

UPDATE OCTOBER 2024: REGULATING MUSICAL TEMPO

I originally wrote all of this earlier this year, 2024. But, I just saw something pop up that BLOWS MY MIND yet completely underscores my point of how ridiculous AND dangerous it can be when government regulation goes too far. The the NPR article below: "Chechnya is banning music that's too fast or slow. These songs wouldn't make the cut." What!!! That's insanity!

Chechnya is banning music that's too fast or slow. These songs wouldn't make the cut

Video: Chechnya is banning music that's too fast or slow. These songs wouldn't make the cut

What is their reason for this? It is to keep out people and cultural elements that the government does not approve of:

"Musical, vocal and choreographic" works will be limited to a tempo of 80 to 116 beats per minute (BPM) to "conform to the Chechen mentality and sense of rhythm," said Dadayev, according to the Russian state-run news agency TASS. "Borrowing musical culture from other peoples is inadmissible," Dadayev said, per a translation by The Guardian. "We must bring to the people and to the future of our children the cultural heritage of the Chechen people. This includes the entire spectrum of moral and ethical standards of life for Chechens."

That is so wrong at so many levels and should make freedom loving people's blood run cold. Now, take my whole compare zoning law to music and use this BPM Music Ban in Chechnya as an example. When we say in our communities we don't want certain kinds of housing, especially when it is driven by the idea that we don't want certain kinds of people, it is just as wrong and dangerous as the Music Ban. When cities ban 5,000 square foot lots, or 8,000 square foot lots, or apartments, all of which I have seen and continue to see, it is like banning music that happens to be 117 BPM or anything faster than this ridiculous 116 BPM threshold.

I originally wrote the metaphor above as sort of a funny way to address a very serious topic thinking that in reality we would NEVER regulate music in the over-reaching way we regulate land use policy. Yet, here it is happening in modern times, albeit in a former Soviet State, far worse than anything I conjured up above. This is the Chains that Bind! This is the Common Good becoming Common Bondage. We must STOP over-regulating ourselves to paralysis and oblivion.

Update March 2026: Kennedy Center

The Kennedy Center situation has turned into a tragic fiasco and a lesson in the price we pay when we put government in charge and in ownership of something as important as music and art. What should be a place for beauty and art has gotten caught in the crossfire of the ugly political divisions ripping through the rest of our culture. I can’t stand the idea of any government entity, power, agency, or person controlling what art and music gets to be programmed and defined as the symbol of our culture. Think about everything I just said about government dictating music and now imagine any government official from any side of the political spectrum making those choices. Whether you like those people or not, whether you like their politics or not, that is a recipe for bad things to happen with good music and art destined to be the ultimate casualty.

Think about how we got here. The left has historically been the political party of increased government and public control and ownership of things (property, money, thought, vision, you name it). In a bizarre twist, in some areas, the political right is starting drift from its freedom loving small government origins to now flirting more and more with a more government, less freedom kind of direction. That is a problem when private property owners (like me) are being told what they can and can’t do. When a thing is government owned (like the Kennedy Center is), that same mob rule mentality gets dramatically escalated. And, since the mob owns and pay for it, of course they are going to weigh in, as they should. The outcome is that music and art become a political football subject to the whims and winds of the last election cycle.

This a classic illustration of how the ideal of public ownership and control for public good inevitably gets hijacked and wrecked by the reality that power hungry people always succumb to unrighteous dominion. It is a fairy tale that in reality is a nightmare. All you get is loss of public good along with loss of freedom. The Kennedy Center represents the next level of something being “owned” by everyone, in this case music, and as a result being subject to the whims of the mob. I can see how a lot of people cringe at the idea of Trump setting the standard for art and music in this country. I actually connect with a lot of the music that speaks to the Trump crowd. Waylon and Alan Jackson and gritty old Classic Rock are deep in my DNA. I've hosted Lee Greenwood and shared a stage with him for a Constitution Week Event and I get sincerely moved with he sings "God Bless The USA." But, my greatest love in music is jazz and symphonic music. I'm guessing Trump would have his typical nasty things to say about the music I love and revere (Mahler, Miles, Shostakovich, Stravinsky, Cecil Taylor, Keith Jarret, Chick Corea, etc.).

My classical and jazz music friends (people that mean the world to me) are generally pretty repulsed by what Trump has done with The Kennedy Center image and programming. But, I also have a ton of friends and family in the Trump/MAGA world who probably don't like the idea of their tax dollars paying for music that doesn't mean anything to them and think its awesome what Trump did. I think music by people like Mahler is of transcendent importance and I deeply desire everyone else to hear and love it too. But, I also understand acutely the danger of using government to drive or subsidize that. Just like I don’t want someone like Trump deciding what music should be in our great concert halls, I wouldn’t want anyone else in government controlling that either, from any place on the political pendulum.

Stalin was the ultimate leftist (communism) and the ultimate right-wing extremist (fascism). He pretty much covered the entire spectrum of brutal and catastrophic extreme government control. Look what he did to Shostakovich’s musical and artistic freedom. That is where this ends up. That is the course we’ve set ourselves on by fostering a culture of everyone owning and controlling everything. To many it might seem harmless to attack the property rights of a land developer like me. But, that is how the culture and social expectation gets built that ends up where all rights and all freedoms get attacked and lost to the frenzy of politics and the mob. We are seeing this catastrophe play out in front of us now and everything good about our lives, freedom, and culture will eventually be lost to this. The chains with which we bind our neighbor will someday bind us. Common good eventually becomes common bondage. I have the deepest respect for Wynton Marsalis, a brilliant musician, and the founding head of Jazz and Lincoln Center. Lincoln Center is perhaps the finest musical venue in this nation, maybe in the world. See here my thoughts on Wynton and the principle of chains that bind.