Brief Summary:
Arizona’s HB 2570 correctly recognized that excessive local regulation restricts housing supply and increases prices, but its solution would have swung the pendulum too far by stripping cities of important planning authority. The better approach is a balanced partnership among state and local government, developers, and communities—reducing unreasonable barriers while preserving appropriate standards for quality, compatibility, and long-term livability. I wrote this letter to the Governor in March 2024 using my personal and family history of working with local government to demonstrate a balanced way forward.
Preface and Context for Letter to The Governor
Monday, March 12, 2024
In the 2024 Arizona Legislative Session, House Bill 2570 passed both houses and was sent to the Governor's office for signature. The intent of the bill was to address the housing affordability and availability issue by dialing back the regulatory authority local cities and counties have over single-family residential housing development. Among other things, cities with a population over 70,000 would have no say on single family residential architectural design, amenities, HOA requirements, walls and fences, lot coverage, and setback requirements above 5 feet side yard, 10 feet front and back, lot sizes over 1,500 square feet. For context, in today's housing stock, a lot size of 5,000 feet is considered small and entry level. 3,000 square feet is extremely small and uncommon. 1,500 square feet as lot size (not home size) is surprisingly small.
I have written and spoken extensively about how the pendulum in land use regulation has swung too far to the side of over-regulation. Specific to this issue, I have written how zoning law has evolved over time from its original proper intent to a new and over-reaching purpose and harmful outcome. All too often, land use regulation goes too far, much farther than most of us would tolerate in any other part of our lives or our shared economy. Thus, I am deeply appreciative of the Arizona legislative bodies for recognizing this huge issue and seeking to address it. Senate President Warren Petersen, a primary advocate of HB 2570, is a long time personal friend. I am grateful for him and others like him spending decades in elected office working to advance freedom and pull government away from over-reach and back towards its proper role. Currently nearly all control of housing product rests with local jurisdictions. Landowners and developers have very limited say or control. There is no question in my mind that something needs to be corrected. And, there is no question in my mind that pushing control back into the marketplace, an essential driver that is all too often disregarded, will increase supply and decrease home prices. That is simple and fundamental market economics. I believe deeply in freedom and free markets. The legislature is wise to recognize this and advocate for these foundational Constitutional principles.
Having said that, in spite of my freedom loving, regulatory resistant personality, I have also come to respect and even embrace that some reasonable amount of regulation is appropriate for land development. I regularly push back on regulation that goes too far while respecting the need for regulation that makes sense. My messaging is all about balance. This web site is called "Pendulum BALANCE," not "Swing the Pendulum Out of the Way So I Can Do What I Want!" So, if I am going to advocate balancing the pendulum away from too much government control, I need to acknowledge that it goes both ways. HB 2570 seeks to address very real issues and is causing us to look closely at the pros and cons of specific tools local government uses to regulate residential development. That is an important conversation to have and I'm glad we are having it. Some of those regulatory tools need to be adjusted. But, in my view as a multi-generational developer who has spent decades working with elected officials, professional staff, and neighbors, HB 2570 swings the pendulum too far in the direction of "not enough government." That says a lot coming from a guy who has experienced extreme frustration and distress as a result of the pendulum being swung for so long to the other side of "too much government."
With all that context in mind, my message below to The Governor should make more sense coming from me. To all of my friends and colleagues who work on the government side of this and have spent years hearing my intense passion about pulling the pendulum back away from the government side, I hope you can see my sincerity in trying not to pull it too far over to the developer side that we lose balance the other way. Read what I have written extensively for years about balancing the pendulum, long before this issue came to a head. That is balance. I ask it of you who serve in government, so I must ask it of myself as a property owner and land developer. To my friends in government, both elected and staff, who have for years been honest and sincere in working to keep this pendulum in balance, thank you. If everyone in government treated balance and the need to govern righteously the way you do, we wouldn't even be having this conversation. But, as a general trend in Arizona and really across the country, the pendulum has swung out of balance, for whatever reason, toward too much regulation. HB 2570 is causing us to take a hard look at the cause and effect of that imbalance. Hopefully, it will also cause us to have a healthy, even-handed conversation about bringing that pendulum back into balance. Here is my view on that conversation as expressed to the Governor of Arizona:
EMAIL SUBJECT:
HB 2570 - A Multigenerational Developer's PerspectiveMarch 12, 2024
Honorable Governor Hobbs:
HB 2570, the Arizona Starter Home Act, seeks to solve a very real problem. However, I do not believe HB 2570 is the right solution. Please continue the vigorous pursuit of solutions to the very critical housing affordability and availability issue. The status quo has become untenable. However, for reasons I shall explain further, please pursue alternative solutions other than HB 2570.
I am a sixth generation Arizona native and a land developer. My family arrived in the valley in 1878. We have made our way here as farmers, ranchers, dam builders, laborers, entrepreneurs, tech innovators, and for the past 50 years, land developers. We have been part of the delivery of tens of thousands of residential housing units with tens of thousands more in inventory, regional commercial hubs, office and industrial developments, and more. Because we are multi-generational in this valley, we see development activity, both benefits and impacts, generationally. Good development, including good working relationships with our friends and counterparts in local government matters greatly to us. Over the years, we’ve seen many jurisdictions cultivate a thoughtful relationship with the development community balancing reasonable regulatory oversight with market realities in bringing the full gamut of quality development and growth to Arizona in a true spirit of partnership. In some jurisdictions we’ve seen the regulatory environment grow in counterproductive, unreasonable ways that do not balance economic and market realities. This is most often driven by existing residents either resisting any new residential development, or vigorously opposing any development that is “less than” or different than what they currently live in. Social medial has been a means for this dynamic to grow exponentially. Elected officials and city and county planning professionals are under immense pressure to accommodate community calls to shut down or shut out all kinds of development. More affordable higher density and multifamily projects are the most common target of this push back. I can say as one being regulated, there absolutely is a proper role for reasonable regulatory oversight of development. As someone who sees development generationally, I applaud and welcome the desire and collaboration to build quality, well-planned communities. Mitigating concerns of neighbors and community is an essential part of the development process. But, that has become increasingly difficult, sometimes impossible, and has driven up cost and constrained the supply of new housing. There are certainly many other factors driving the current housing crisis, but this continual escalation of the regulatory environment is certainly a primary cause.
I say all this to illustrate from the vantage point of someone with decades of experience as a developer, I see both sides of this issue. I see and value the critical need of community engagement, zoning ordinances, design guidelines, site plans approvals, and the other myriad of steps it takes to go from raw land to housing product, or any other type of product for that matter. I also see how onerous and unreasonable this all can become when it gets out of balance with economic and market realities. The essential guiding principle here must be BALANCE. Without enough regulatory oversight, the quality and livability of our communities suffers, especially for future generations. With too much regulation, the market becomes less and less able to meet consumer demand and homes prices just go up and up. For some time in some jurisdictions, that pendulum has swung too far in the direction of over-regulation. Simply put, our collective well-meaning demand for better and better quality and design combined with resistance to new product and new development has contributed to pricing most people out of the market. Thus, the problem HB 2570 seeks to solve is very real.
However, with BALANCE being the essential guiding principle, HB 2570 swings the pendulum too far the other direction by eliminating local government oversight. HB 2570 is punitive and harmful to jurisdictions that are sincerely trying AND succeeding at striking this balance and partnership. We should not cut short the good work these communities are doing and disrupt the great progress they are making at bringing new product to market. Communities and neighbors still need to be able to engage with the development community. Thought still needs to be given to compatibility, transitions, buffers, design standards, and the other good planning practices we’ve relied on to make Arizona such an attractive and livable place. I work and develop in some great communities and see on a daily basis the positive, productive effort they are making to be partners, not adversaries in this cause. For communities where the regulatory pendulum has swung too far, we should find other approaches to help these communities move toward putting that pendulum in the balanced middle where it belongs.
My father began developing in Arizona in the 1970’s. As he taught me the business, he taught the need to build quality and to think about how what we built would stand the test of time. I distinctly remember him talking about proposing and advocating for Gilbert’s first set of design standards. He called then Town Manger Kent Cooper one of his closest friends as they worked together on those design guidelines and countless projects that would come to define Gilbert. Those two men, working from opposing and sometimes even conflicting roles, worked together for decades finding that essential BALANCE between regulatory oversight and market reality. I and countless others in the development community still enjoy those kinds of friendships and positive working relationship with professional staff and community leadership across the state. As I have explained, in some jurisdictions, the pendulum has swung away from that BALANCE leaving us now with an over-regulated environment that hinders the market from providing Arizonans with affordable housing. That problem must be solved. But, let’s solve it by seeking solutions that swing the pendulum back to a BALANCED middle. Let’s seek solutions that build on that positive working relationship between local government and the development community. Let’s identify and address the real sources of these real problems then act as partners and friends in building great communities in way that Arizonans can afford. HB 2570 takes local government so far out of the equation that it not only undermines that necessary element of community engagement, but it undermines that spirit of partnership, friendship, and BALANCE I believe is essential in solving these big problems. I suggest a task force of stake holders that includes city and county leaders, professional administrative and planning staff, developers, residential real estate professionals, planning consultants and zoning attorneys, design professionals, architects, economists, and other experts that can speak to all sides of this complicated issue with a purpose to find that balanced middle.
Thank You,
Jason Barney_______________________________
Jason Barney
jason@jasonbarney.com
http://www.JasonBarney.com
480-818-2000
_______________________________
One more note about HB 2570. There is so much more to the housing supply and affordability problem that HB 2570 does not address. I realize that it is the nature of legislation that you can only solve small chunks of big problems small bites at a time. This bill addresses an important aspect of development and housing supply: the rules cities use to govern single family housing. While that seeks to address crisis at hand, the affordability of home ownership, there are other aspects of land use regulation that significantly impact availability and affordability of housing, perhaps even more than design guidelines, lot sizes, and HOA formation. Once a piece of land is entitled to be housing, it is challening and time consuming (12-18 months) to get to a building permit where you can break ground. But, for what it's worth, that's actually the easy part. Getting it to an entitlement where you can even start the process of working through design standards and building permits is vastly more difficult, vastly more time consuming (I've had it take upwards of 16 years), and often impossible. There are many complicated reasons for this.
The biggest reason it is so hard to get new land zoned and approved for new housing is community push back, often referred to as NIMBYism (Not In My Backyard). Existing residents want farm fields to stay farm fields (even if their own house was also a farm field just a few years prior). They also insist that any new development be equal or lesser density than what they have. Acre lot residents resist anything smaller, even half or quarter acre lots. Quarter acre lot residents resist 7,000 SF and 5,000 SF lots. 5,000 SF lot residents resist town homes. And, everyone resists apartments (multifamiy). However, a healthy housing market and supply needs all of that. Density, including higher density single family, attached single family, or multifamily and rental product, whether people like that or not, is a very important part of the housing affordability picture. Yet, largely due to public push back, it has become increasingly difficult to get new multifamily or higher density product approved. Click here for more on how zoning can turn into elitism and exacerbation of the housing supply and affordability problem.
Another reason it is so hard for new land to get approved for housing is the huge pressure cities feel to protect their sales tax base. Most cities rely dominantly on sales tax for their fiscal survival. The more sales tax generating land use they have, the more revenue that have to work with. That generally means retail. The problem is, not all land that is zoned for commercial is actually viable as commercial. Retail is the most location dependent of all land uses. If you don't have a good location, or if you don't have the traffic counts, or if you don't have the surrounding rooftops, or if you have a submarket that is oversaturated with other competing retail, or if your site conditions or geometry are wrong, then new retail will not and cannot get built no matter how much you want it.
This is a structural problem. Cities rely so heavily on sales tax for revenue they feel huge pressure to hold out for retail sites that just don't work, no matter how badly anyone wants it. Retail is always worth substially more money, so land owners would rather have retail too, but only if it is viable. If it is not vailable, it can be a devastating chokehold to a land owner. But, driven by the strucutural pressure for cities to need sales tax revenue, it is not uncommon for cities to refuse to rezone land from commercial to residential even when that land is not market viable for that use. It is also common for other best practice principles to suggest that a site is really more appropriate for residential uses, but cities look past those important considerations under this pressure to preserve commercial.
This results in land that sits indefinitely or permanently undeveloped, providing no benefit to the city, including no sales tax. While it could become part of the housing supply offsetting the availability and affordability problem, AND could bring new rooftops to support retail in locations that actually are viable, it instead sits vacant, in stalemate to unrealistic expectations. Typically elected officials and professional staff are good people trying to do the right thing in their role. But, the system is structured in a way that pressures them to use their authority in ways that don't make market sense, are extremely harmful to landowners, and in spite of best intentions, actually hurt the city and community by mistakenly constricting market supply of much needed housing product.
In these situations, landowners and developers are completely at the mercy of the local jurisdiction when seeking rezoning of land caught in these "no way forward" situations. Currently there is no burden on cities to prove up or validate those expectations to insist on non-viable land remaining commercial. They can just say no. Because they feel so compelled to preserve sales tax generating land uses, whether those locations are viable or not, they do say no on a regular basis. Property owners have no recourse no matter how unrealistic the city's reasoning is for saying no.
I've written quite a bit more about these and other issues including this on The Origins and Evolution of Zoning Law. As I call for the Governor to continue the hard work of solving these hard problems, these are just some of many additional issues that also need to be addressed beyond the scope of HB2570.
Monday, March 18, 2024 UPDATE (One Week Later)
Governor Hobbs vetoed HB 2570.
I sincerely hope this is the beginning, not the end of the dialog to address deeply needed changes to how we regulate land use in Arizona. I look forward to rigorous, thoughtful, and intellectually honest discussion with community leaders, state government, fellow developers, and real estate professionals of all kinds to figure out how to get this right. HB 2570 focused primarily on single family housing regulation and the issue of affordability and availability of housing. However, the issue of land use regulation goes far beyond just that. There are basic market and economic issues to reconcile not just in single family housing development, but all types of land development. The most important to me, there are Constitutional Property Rights issues to reconcile. For the past few decades, the evolution of the land use regulatory process has focused almost exclusively on increasing quality and excluding land uses of all kinds that local jurisdictions perceive to be undesirable, all of which is highly subjective and vulnerable to the shifting winds of personal opinion and misinformation. Very little concern has been given to market viability, the regional economic outcomes of policy decisions that have been made, the economic impacts to the millions of families and households in Arizona, or the troubling dilution of the fundamental Constitutional Principle of property rights. Now, we are having to face the implications of ignoring these issues. That pendulum has been moving farther and farther to the side of government regulation for a long time and we are now starting to see the cost. Although HB 2570 would have swung the pendulum too far in the opposite direction, I am grateful for the conversation it has started and the light it has shown on the price we pay as a society, as a state, as families, as communities, when we do not balance the pendulum.
There is a WIDE array of views on these issues and the right solutions. I certainly have mine. Some say there is no problem with over-regulation and that cities are doing just fine responding to the market. Others see just the opposite. The truth and the right way forward lies somewhere in the middle and at the end of a long, hard conversation where everyone is willing to listen, learn, adapt, compromise, and think past old beliefs that may be holding us all back.
Here is one notable view of whether this topic needs attention. Over 60 years ago, 1964, President Reagan warned that even at that time, we were in danger of the pendulum swinging so far toward too much government that that fundamental Constitutional right to property was in danger. In my view, the pendulum has only swung further, much further, in the decades since.
"Now it doesn't require expropriation or confiscation of private property or business to impose socialism on a people. What does it mean whether you hold the deed or the title to your business or property if the government holds the power of life and death over that business or property? Such machinery already exists. The government can find some charge to bring against any concern it chooses to prosecute. Every businessman has his own tale of harassment. Somewhere a perversion has taken place. Our natural, inalienable rights are now considered to be a dispensation of government, and freedom has never been so fragile, so close to slipping from our grasp as it is at this moment." President Ronald Regan (Full Text and Video Here - Direct Link to Quote Here)
So yes, let's fix this. Let's not break it the other direction, but let's fix it.
Here are just a few articles I have seen that continue this conversation: